Saturday, August 23, 2008

Eating Disorders and Athletic Participation

With the passage of Title IX, more and more women have been participating in athletics. Although participation in sports has many benefits--including teamwork, fitness, and fun--it also brings a risk of eating disorders, especially at an elite level. A recent study from the International Journal of Eating Disorders, led by Jill Holm-Denoma (now of the University of Denver), looked at eating disordered attitudes and behaviors in relation to level of athletic participation and sports anxiety.

Women who participate in intercollegiate varsity athletics have much higher rates of eating disorder symptomatology when compared to women in club sports, independent exercisers and non-exercisers. Furthermore, higher levels of sports anxiety (that is, anxiety about physical activity and/or sports) were predictive of increased levels of bulimic symptoms and a drive for thinness.

Varsity athletes have devoted much of their recent lives to their sport, increasing both their identity with athletics and the pressure to perform well. As well, it could be that eating disordered attitudes and behaviors are normalized, tolerated, or even encouraged. Traits of obsessionality and perfectionism are risk factors for eating disorders, that may also cause a woman to excel at the varsity level.

Yet the results show an interesting variation. Writes Holm-Denoma:

Despite the trend for women who participated in higher levels of athletic competition to have higher levels of eating disorders, our data do not suggest a clear dimension ranging from nonexercisers to varsity athletes. In some cases, for instance, independent exercisers appear to have similar traits to varsity athletes (e.g., see Fig. 1). Thus, some independent exercisers may engage in exercise as frequently and/or intensely as women who participate in competitive athletics.

It appears that some women with eating disorders (or their accompanying attitudes) exercise alone, independently, and perhaps obsessively. This could perhaps come from a desire to hide their disorder.

The researchers conclude that:

Coaches and clinicians should be aware that athletes experience higher rates of eating disorder symptoms than nonathletes. Moreover, sports anxiety should be considered as a possible target of therapy among athletes.

(cross-posted at ED Bites)


Palmtreechick said...

I was a division 1, 2 sport athlete in college. I can think of two teammates, not including myself, whom suffered from eating disorders. I would workout before practice or after practice. After I graduated I felt as though my identity as an athlete was gone, that I had no way of describing myself. I was no longer "an athlete."

At 30 years old I'm still playing sports and still disordered, but I'm still no longer "an athlete."

Anonymous said...

You're right, disordered eating is definitely a major concern amongst athletes at all levels. It is, without a doubt, something that needs serious attention. Recently, the Center for Eating Disorders at Sheppard Pratt posted an article discussing pressures put on athletes to maintain a certain body image, and the health risks involved. To read the article you can go here:

Anonymous said...

People fail in accelerating weight loss due to various reasons such as the lack of a well-managed dieting schedule and also for not practicing physical exercises regularly. Altogether, if you are not aware of comprehensive weight loss information, including weight loss tips, it is also likely to slacken your weight loss regimen and as such you should instantly visit the site and enhance your knowledge on various weight loss details before starting off your anti-obesity regimen.